The U.S. Department of Justice published its response to two public comments on November 9, 2026, defending a proposed antitrust judgment that would restrict the data Willow Bridge Property Company can use to set rents. The restrictions would cover both offers to new tenants and renewals for existing tenants. The department’s Federal Register response says it will ask the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina to enter the judgment. An earlier stipulation already requires Willow Bridge to follow the proposed terms while the court process runs.
Key facts
- The proposal covers conventional multifamily rental properties that Willow Bridge services in the United States and its territories.
- It restricts software that uses competitors’ nonpublic data and software that pools data from Willow Bridge properties with different owners.
- The Justice Department says the data restrictions apply to renewal prices as well as offers to prospective tenants.
- The proposed judgment provides for compliance audits and government inspections. It does not provide renter restitution.
What changes when a manager prices apartments for different owners?
In the amended complaint, the United States and participating states alleged that Willow Bridge and competing landlords supplied RealPage with granular, nonpublic data on lease renewals, terms and prices. Prosecutors say that information went into software that helped set rents across competing properties. A manager considering a price for an available apartment could therefore receive a recommendation shaped by recent transactions that other landlords had kept private. The complaint alleges that sharing those inputs and using common pricing tools weakened competition among landlords. Justice Department response, section II
The proposed remedy draws a boundary inside the manager’s own portfolio as well. Willow Bridge can manage properties for more than one owner. Under the proposed judgment it could not use a revenue management product that pools information from properties with different owners simply because Willow Bridge manages them all. The department’s July settlement announcement also describes restrictions on pricing algorithms that use competitors’ data and on exchanging competitively sensitive information with rival landlords. That gives the restrictions a wider reach than switching from one software vendor to another.
One commenter asked the department to examine cases in which an existing tenant receives a higher renewal offer than a prospective tenant would receive for the same apartment. The department’s answer makes a distinction between the prices and the inputs behind them. It says the same data rules would apply to both offers. A difference between the two prices, on its own, would not establish that Willow Bridge used a competitor’s confidential information or coordinated its prices with a rival. The proposed terms do not require the two offers to match. Justice Department response, section IV.A
That distinction also explains the department’s answer to requests for tenant notices and human review of renewal offers. It declined to add those requirements, arguing that its complaint concerned data sharing and coordination among rivals, rather than the use of automated pricing by itself. The data restrictions govern what can go into a recommendation. The department declined to add a process for renters to find out whether their own property or its data was part of the investigation. Justice Department response, sections IV.A–B
Who can check whether the software follows the rules?
A second commenter asked for independent technical verification of outside software. The department pointed instead to a certification and monitoring arrangement. If Willow Bridge uses a third-party pricing product without a certification that meets the decree’s terms, the proposal provides for a court-appointed monitor. The department also says it could inspect the code and pseudocode of Willow Bridge’s own pricing software. Those are different checks: a certification from an outside supplier, a monitor where the terms require one, and direct government access to the manager’s proprietary code. July settlement announcement · Justice Department response, section IV.B
The internal audit would cover staff involved in revenue management and at least 12 randomly selected local, regional or supervisory property operations employees. That figure is a minimum count of people in the latter group, rather than a sample size for apartment buildings or lease quotes. The government would also be able to obtain relevant records and interview employees. The department rejected the commenter’s proposal for a public annual report, citing the decree’s confidentiality provisions and the risk of disclosing sensitive business information to competing landlords. Justice Department response, section IV.B
For tenants, coverage depends on the kind of property and who services it. The department says conventional multifamily properties serviced by Willow Bridge across the United States and its territories would be covered. The definition excludes categories such as student, affordable, age-restricted or senior, and military housing. Coverage also does not create a refund mechanism: the department says its complaint did not seek restitution, and the proposed judgment contains none. Justice Department response, section IV.B
What happens in court now?
The department filed its response on November 5, after the public comment period on the July proposal. It says it will move for entry after publication of the comments and response. Under the Tunney Act procedure described in the filing, the district court then decides whether entry is in the public interest. The November 9 notice gives no decision date. If entered, the judgment will resolve the United States’ claims against Willow Bridge, and the court will retain authority to enforce its terms. The next court filing to watch is the government’s motion for entry. Justice Department response, sections I, III and V



